Viewing Topic

    Time to Up and Move Baby
Dawn Yang - If by foreign workers you mean

1

 

and

2


then ... why, heellllooooo there and welcome to the 'hood J

But of course I suppose a hothouse of supermodels is about as likely to grace my street as the girls on ANTM eating anything more than a salad per day.

Unfortunately, the prospect of 1000 Bangladeshi, Thai and Indian workers suddenly popping up opposite my home is not exactly going to bring a smile to my face.

Thankfully I live in a private residential area in Bukit Timah, hence chances of that happening are probably very slim.

I'm not going to be politically correct and say that I do not care nor mind if such an event really did take place.

First, watch my property price plummet. This is inevitable, and one cannot deny this will happen.

I do see a few these foreign workers here and there due to new houses being built around my neighborhood, and honestly, I'm quite alright with them; they usually hardly register a bleep on my attention radar. However, 1000 of them? Permanently staying opposite me? Day in and day out? They will outnumber even us residents! I'm sorry but I do not want to be living in construction-worker town.

Having paid top dollar to live in a nice place, one would be aghast to know you now have to come home everyday to lorries ferrying workers dirty from construction, these men drinking, loitering, gambling, or being rowdy. I don't know exactly how bad it will really be, maybe my fears are unfounded, but the chances (from hearsay too) are there.

I'd also be concerned about safety - according to police reports foreign workers account for about 14% of total persons arrested for crime.

Then, there is the leering! All females should know what I'm talking about here. One, two, or three are already enough, I will not be able to stand having hundreds of eyes gazing after me each time I walk home. It is highly disturbing and unsettling to be mentally undressed over and over. I am speaking from experience and other females I've spoken to feel the same way. And what if.. just what if.. late at night, one of them loses control of himself one day and assaults me, or any other girl in the neighborhood?

Time to up and move baby.

I don't hate foreign workers nor am I racist in any way, but what I do believe is that choosing a place to live is a very personal preference. You have to feel comfortable in your sanctuary that you call home. The surroundings and location play a big part in one's choice of where to live - people look at everything from potentially annoying neighbors, to whether it is in front of a noisy main road, or what direction of sun the house gets. And in the same vein, a dormitory housing 1000 foreign workers opposite a potential home is not quite going to cut it.

Foreign workers do the jobs we Singaporeans loathe to do; we really should appreciate them for this, and make them feel more welcome. I recognize this fact, but yet, how many of us do not balk at the idea of living opposite so many of them? Sad to say, in this way, I feel rather hypocritical :(



Email-Links Comments (31) Printable 20152 Views Bookmark and Share
  Comments for: A dormitory housing 1,000 foreign workers is set up opposite your home. What is your reaction? What will you do? : Time to Up and Move Baby
  Comments:
 
Posted by jjjeeennn on 02-11-2008
I'm very shocked when I read your article. It's such a mean thing to say.
Even in this world, not many people know that Singapore is really exist. I've chatted with a Caucasian frm UK, and she doesn't even know where exactly Singapore is!
And I thought ever one in Singapore is taught Social Studies, celebrated Racial Harmony Day and so on? Why not we think about win-win solution and not complain?

I'm just a 17 year old Indonesian girl who's been studying in Singapore for 3 years. Pardon me for my immature comment :)
Posted by MrsEriclee on 28-10-2008
I live in a private residential in serangoon but not serangoon garden, another part of the private housing.. at the back of my house lived a house of foreign workers from china and india.. they never gives any problem and they carry much dignity in their life, many times I walk over the small walkway back to my house at late night, i can see these workers sitting..chatiting on their mobile phones to probably cure the home sickness they have miles away. They don't litter , they dont create nuisance.. but some guys i know that is rich enough to have a few lprivate property is the REAL NUIISANCE!
Bear in mind that Foreign worker are here to earn a living , this is not nessasry that their heart belong to this country. And they probably have a family back in their home country and all they want to do is earn enough to pay off whoever trafficker who take a huge cut on their wages for their pass and then work somemore to send back home .. DO you Seriously think they want to create problem and be ask to leave this country penniless -very likely.
I have travel half the globe and I can tell u..racist is a very serious and sensitive issue.. if we don't do something to stop it.. it will just be carry on likely from one generation to another.
And one day, one day...u 'll never know that it is Them that you refer as lowly educated,litter bugs..that actually saves your life. Have an open mind foreign worker are just like you and i.. if you don't get it.. go to the kitchen and get a knife.. have a thin cut on your arm and you will know what i meant.. for whatever differences.. our body are running the same color of blood.
Posted by howareyoudude on 23-10-2008
Hi Dawn, you may ignore those who call for your head!!!

Your opinion that clearly collates with the residents who protested. Who really cares about the welfare and dignity of the "uncivilised foreign worker"? If you really care for them, do something to improve their living conditions, and don't just talk.

At least Dawn is frank to say what she thinks like many people from the unpopular side.

My comment is we can feel sorry for them, but that's the life you have to live as a foreign manual worker, it doesn't matter where you worked in ... Australia, US, middle east. You'll get the same treatment from the locals all the time.
Posted by elsteroy on 22-10-2008
Dear Dawn,

I am truly appalled that you feel that way. I live in a foreign country occupied predominantly by Caucasians and there are some who have habits that are downright disgusting. They too drink, loiter, gamble and can become rowdy. How you behave in public is not determined by your race. Surely you are aware of that? Oh and construction workers are not the only ones who leer at women. Why are Singaporeans coming down so hard on foreign workers? What problems are we solving by simply criticising and discriminating against them? Perhaps we should look for solutions. Educate them. Allow them to learn about us and we about them.

Just because you've added the line "I don't hate foreign workers nor am I racist in any way" does not redeem you of racism or discrimination. Yes, where you choose to live is a personal preference. But I believe that these foreign workers can choose to live wherever they please and if they are not given that option, their companies or the government can choose to put them wherever they deem fit. Who are you to tell other people (humans, much like you) where they can or cannot live?

What has Singapore become? We used to give the US and Australia so much flak for discriminating against us Asians but aren't we doing the same now?

Ignorance is not bliss little miss.
Posted by kyochan19792002 on 22-10-2008
Dear Dawn,

In the past, we Chinese were badly discriminated by the others. Even now, Chinese are still not too welcomed in some countries.

Instead of saying "1,000 foreign workers", you should say "1,000 uncivilized foreign workers". This is more appropriate and less racist!
Posted by starrynitezz on 21-10-2008
In God's eyes, everyone is the same. Who are you to say these foreign workers are any different from the fairer skinned foreigners?

Most of our grandparents or great grandparents came from China too.

Moreover, please remember they are the ones who had built our homes, and Singapore needs them as our fellow Singaporeans are not so keen on doing the work.

If you do not like the sight of them, maybe you could consider relocating to the other countries, and you see what kind of reaction you would get.
Posted by missparadox on 21-10-2008
Hokkaido_gal,

Pot. Kettle. Black. 'CHINA IS NOTHING'??? Racist much? It is attitude like yours that resulted in your armies committing genocide in China during WWII. But then again, you wouldn't know that because they don't teach you that in Japanese schools.

Shame on you.
Posted by SarahWatson on 20-10-2008
In your own words,
"Imagine if it were 1000 white construction workers from Aussie (where they are aplenty) who moved to the dorms instead. Would we mind as much?

Even if there is some unhappiness, would the element of fear, disgust and worry be as strong? I doubt so."

I am a scientist that have worked and lived as an expat in Singapore for 4 years from 2001. I have since left, as I found living back in Australia (where I was born) so much more welcoming. Shocking, since I'm treated as a demi-goddess in Singapore, what with being a professional/expat and a being Caucasian (as inferred by your inane ramblings, as being 'superior').

I have to say that I am completely gobsmacked at the level of ignorance some people show with regards to 'fairer' communities. No, my dear girl, having 1000 blue collar, uneducated workers at your doorstep is not 'better' than anything else. People are people, regardless of colour. Just because Australian construction workers are white doesn't make them less smelly, behave less leery towards women, or any less rowdy. Not all Caucasians are well built, handsome, or smart. There will always be the runts of the litters. You get that in ALL communities, even in supposed first world countries. A person should never be valued on their skin colour, just purely by they do.

Maybe one day you will wake up from your juvenile fairytale princess life and see the world as it is. Until then, god bless.
Posted by justfriend on 20-10-2008
Haha, Dick Lee teaching etiquette.

Our government has acknowledged that many foreigners from many parts of the world still do not know about us. Very soon this is going to be a thing of a past with the IR coming, F1, globalisation, free trade, internationalized Arts, etc.

I wonder what will be the reaction of the people in US or London or perhaps Japan if a large group of these similar workers move in to their neighbourhood. But I guess this will never happen as their countries have more land to spare.
Posted by hokkaido_gal on 20-10-2008
TO DAWN YANG,
YOU ARE EXTREMELY RACIST. JUST REMEMBER, SINGAPORE WAS BUILD BY THE HANDS OF THE LABORERS.

DO YOU KNOW THAT SINGAPOREANS IN OTHER PARTS OF THE WORLD ARE ALSO BEING DISCRIMINATED?

THE SG WOMEN ARE SEEN AS FROM CHINA DUE TO FACIAL SIMILARITIES AND THEREFORE ARE VERY OFTEN CLASSIFIED AS PROSTITUTES.

SG MEN ARE CALLED CHINAMAN.

ALL OF THESE ABOVE STATEMENTS ARE BASED ON MY OWN EXPERIENCES AS AN ASIAN LIVING IN THE GULF.

DON'T EVER THINK THAT SINGAPOREANS ARE MUCH SUPERIOR THAN THOSE FOREIGN WORKERS COZ IN THE EYES OF THE OUTSIDE WORLD, SINGAPORE IS JUST AN INTEGRATED PART OF CHINA. AND CHINA IS NOTHING.

FOR YOUR INFORMATION, I AM A JAPANESE LIVING IN THE MIDDLE EAST.
Posted by theweirdone on 19-10-2008
damnmorgan,

We don't look down on them because they are Asians, but because they are, the majority of them anyway, sadly, uncivilized in the way they present themselves.It is the same way you would treat a British digging his nose, or an Australian peeing in public, right?

I personally am not able to be so magnanimous and say, hey they are Asians and so am I. Let them stare at all the womenfolk with lust and curiosity, and let them get drunk under my void deck all they want. We are all Asians. I must embrace them like family.

I would only welcome them with open arms once they improve their personal hygiene and behavior.
Posted by justfriend on 16-10-2008
Hmm, talking about color... what if the 1000 foreign workers are Middle East people from Saudi, UAE? May be the reaction may change somewhat.

What if the government gives rebates for Serangoon residents, do you think it helps little? People say money can change the whole situation.
Posted by Dawn.Yang on 16-10-2008
Hi Jane!

I'm glad you brought that up, I was hoping someone would notice the subtle point I was trying to make :)

Imagine if it were 1000 white construction workers from Aussie (where they are aplenty) who moved to the dorms instead. Would we mind as much?

Even if there is some unhappiness, would the element of fear, disgust and worry be as strong? I doubt so.

I have always thought that the level of prejudice and racism many people feel might have a positive relationship with the darkness of skin tone. The darker Bangladeshis turn people off more than the lighter-skinned Thai workers? Likewise Blacks and Latinos perhaps? Just a theory :)

Maybe it has something to do with as you said the messy/dirty/grimy factor associated with darker colors. But even in India, fairer indians like your darling Shah Rukh Khan are deemed more "noble" and upper-class, that's why whitening creams are in such demand there.



Posted by Dawn.Yang on 16-10-2008
Hey RC,

hahah true that about the mega sales creating demand... im sure most of us have experienced that first hand! ;)
Posted by Dawn.Yang on 16-10-2008
"There's nothing contradictory or hypocritical about getting foreign workers to do the jobs we wouldn't do ourselves and our not wanting them in the neighbourhood. Indeed, they are two sides of the same coin, or, if you like, manifestations of the same attitude."

Hey Ju, you kind of have a point there. I reckon then my feelings of hypocrisy stem from an inner conflict - seeing it morally right to treat them as equal humans, but yet in action, I have prejudices and tend to relegate them to the lower castes of our society.